In-Stock Ice Cream Cakes

Magill's is always ready for your next special event with freezers full of ice cream cakes in all the most popular flavors and sizes!​  Our cakes are stocked daily in 3 convenient sizes:

  • 7" to serve up to 10 people

  • 8" to serve 10-12 people

  • sheet cakes to serve 12-15 people

Cakes are made of two layers of Magill's homemade ice cream separated by a layer of chocolate cookie crunch, vanilla cookie crunch or fudge, depending on the cake or whether it is gluten free. That means that you get every flavor and the delicious crunch in every single bite!

Magill's makes cakes daily in everyone's favorite flavor combinations: chocolate/vanilla, chocolate/chocolate, vanilla/cookies & cream, vanilla/mint chocolate chip, strawberry/vanilla, turtle/vanilla, birthday cake/vanilla.

Need a cake now? Order one of our in-stock cakes and pick it up in one hour with your special greeting written on the cake. Click the button and scroll down to cakes to order now (Some cakes are occasionally not available due to demand.)

Custom-Made Ice Cream Cakes

If our in-stock cakes are not in the size or flavors you prefer, you can order a custom cake at least 72 hours in advance of your event. These cakes are prepared the same way and look identical to our in-stock cakes but are made just for you. Custom cakes are offered in a variety of sizes and flavors to suit the tastes of your guests. If you have 3 days to wait for your little masterpiece, click the order button and the form will guide you!